digplanet beta 1: Athena
Share digplanet:

Agriculture

Applied sciences

Arts

Belief

Business

Chronology

Culture

Education

Environment

Geography

Health

History

Humanities

Language

Law

Life

Mathematics

Nature

People

Politics

Science

Society

Technology

In the philosophy of law, virtue jurisprudence is the name given to theories of law related to virtue ethics. By making the aretaic turn in legal theory, virtue jurisprudence focuses on the importance of character and human excellence or virtue to questions about the nature of law, the content of the law, and judging.

The topics encompassed by virtue jurisprudence[edit]

Among the topics encompassed by virtue jurisprudence are the following:

  1. Virtue ethics has implications for an account of the proper ends of legislation. If the aim of law is to make citizens virtuous (as opposed to maximizing utility or realizing a set of moral rights), what are the implications for the content of the laws?
  2. Virtue ethics has implications for legal ethics. Current approaches to legal ethics emphasize deontological moral theory, i.e. duties to clients and respect for client autonomy, and these deontological approaches are reflected in the various codes of professional conduct that have been devised for lawyers, judges, and legislators.
  3. Accounts of the virtue of justice (in particular, Aristotle and Aquinas’s theories of natural justice) have implications for debates between natural lawyers and legal positivists over the nature of law.
  4. A virtue-centered theory of judging, which describes the particular excellences required by judges.

Aretaic theories of judging[edit]

The judicial virtues[edit]

The most developed aspect of virtue jurisprudence is its distinctive theory of judging. A virtue-centered theory of judging offers an account of the characteristics or excellences that make for a good judge. These include: (1) judicial temperance, (2) judicial courage, (3) judicial temperament, (4) judicial intelligence, (5) judicial wisdom, and (6) justice. Although every theory of judging can incorporate some account of judicial virtue, a virtue-centered theory of judging makes the distinctive claim that the judicial virtues are central, i.e. that they have basic explanatory and normative significance.

Criticism of a virtue-centered theory of judging[edit]

Many of the criticisms of virtue jurisprudence are parallel to those offered in the context of debates over virtue ethics. Some of these include:

  • The charge that virtue jurisprudence does not provide sufficient guidance for the making of legal decisions. "Do as a virtuous judge would do!" This formula provides little instruction to an ordinary decision maker.
  • The argument that virtue jurisprudence requires inordinate trust in the capacities of judges. In a democratic society, the rightness or wrongness of legal decisions should be decided by criteria that are public and accessible to all citizens.

Virtue as the proper end of law[edit]

Aristotle argued that the inculcation of promotion of virtue was the proper end of law. Aquinas argued that true laws (which are rational) can teach virtue by being internalized by those who already possess sufficient virtue to grasp the purpose of the law. Even those who have not yet achieved this level of virtue can be coerced into obedience to the law, and this may enable them to become more virtuous.

A contemporary restatement of this view is found in the writings of Robert George. In his book, Making Men Moral, George argues for the promotion of virtue as the end of law and against the contrary view that the purpose of law is the protection of rights.

Law and virtue outside the Western tradition[edit]

The phrase "virtue jurisprudence" is usually applied in the context of contemporary Western philosophical thinking about law. There are, however, important ideas about the relationship between law and virtue in other intellectual traditions. One example is provided by Confucian ideas about virtue. In the Analects, Confucius argues that a society in which people are virtuous would have no need of judges, rules, or jurisprudence because people would be able to resolve social conflicts by themselves. Thus, it is argued that the idea of virtue is opposed to the idea of law.

It can be argued that that even virtuous citizens might disagree about the application of the law, especially where their own interests or ideological commitments are at stake. However, this argument is rather foreign to both traditional and modern Chinese political thought. Chinese political theory tends to assume that the truly virtuous are selfless to the point of martyrdom and would not consider their own personal interests and that the virtuous are able to transcend ideology. At the same time, traditional Chinese political thought regards those with absolute virtue to be historically extremely rare, and that most people, including the Emperor and his officials, are prone to both corruption and error. Consequently, there is a belief that law and indeed government is an unfortunate necessity in dealing with an imperfect world and with imperfect people.

The view that the inculcation of virtue is the proper end of legislation contrasts markedly with traditional Chinese thinking on the subject, which argues that laws exist because men are lacking in virtue. Confucianism places very little faith on the ability of law or external pressure to make men moral but rather believes that virtue must come from introspection and education. Throughout Chinese political and intellectual history, the Confucian view on law was frequently contrasted in discourse and practice with Chinese Legalist philosophy.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

External links[edit]


Original courtesy of Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_jurisprudence — Please support Wikipedia.
This page uses Creative Commons Licensed content from Wikipedia. A portion of the proceeds from advertising on Digplanet goes to supporting Wikipedia.
1201 videos foundNext > 

Robert P. George: Constitutional Structures, Limited Government, and Civic Virtue [Torrey Lecture]

We are delighted to have Professor Robert P. George join us for this installment of our 2013-14 lecture series, Being Faithful Citizens: Lectures on Rights, ...

Toward a Jurisprudence of the Civil Rights Act

The William H. Timbers '37 Lecture Toward a Jurisprudence of the Civil Rights Act 4:30 PM Rockefeller 003 Co-sponsored by the Dartmouth Legal Studies Faculty...

NAIKE virtue ka aik self test - Maulana Ishaq

Maulana Mufti Ishaq rahmatullah ailah was answering in this video The great Islamic casuist Maulana Mufti Ishaq (rahimullah) was an expert in all jurispruden...

Debating Use of International Law in US Jurisprudence: Deborah Pearlstein & Ilya Shapiro (10/5/2009)

Visiting Faculty Fellow and Lecturer Deborah Pearlstein debates Ilya Shapiro, senior fellow in constitutional studies at the Cato Institute. Event jointly sp...

Grand Opening of The Academy of Research in Islamic Jurisprudence(ARIJ)

Grand Opening of The Academy of Research in Islamic Jurisprudence(ARIJ) on August 23rd, 2012, in the presence of Mufti Ahmed Khanpuri, Mufti Saeed Motara, an...

5/6 Global Ethics Virtue Theory and Abortion

5/6 Global Ethics Virtue Theory and Abortion.

Get the supervision & guidance from Aalim while studying Islamic jurisprudence , Hadees or similar

Maulana Mufti Ishaq rahmatullah ailah was answering in this video The great Islamic casuist Maulana Mufti Ishaq (rahimullah) was an expert in all jurispruden...

Stanza della Segnatura III The Cardinal Virtues

Geoffrey's Gordon's four movement chamber work is inspired by Raphael's frescoes in the Stanza della Segnatura in the Vatican Palace, painted between 1508 an...

Sabr (The Virtue of Patience) Mufti Ismail Menk

Ismail Musa Menk was born in Harare, Zimbabwe. His family originally hails from Gujarat, India. Each year he spends the month of Ramadhaan with a far off com...

Mufti Nazir- Association of purification and jurisprudence

Urdu Dars-e-Quran by mufti Nazir.

1201 videos foundNext > 

We're sorry, but there's no news about "Virtue jurisprudence" right now.

Loading

Oops, we seem to be having trouble contacting Twitter

Talk About Virtue jurisprudence

You can talk about Virtue jurisprudence with people all over the world in our discussions.

Support Wikipedia

A portion of the proceeds from advertising on Digplanet goes to supporting Wikipedia. Please add your support for Wikipedia!