digplanet beta 1: Athena
Share digplanet:

Agriculture

Applied sciences

Arts

Belief

Business

Chronology

Culture

Education

Environment

Geography

Health

History

Humanities

Language

Law

Life

Mathematics

Nature

People

Politics

Science

Society

Technology

The argument from desire is an argument for the existence of God. It is most known in recent times through the writings of C. S. Lewis, for whom it played pivotal role in his own conversion to theism and thence to Christianity.

As a syllogism it can be expressed as follows.

Major premise All innate human desires have objects that exist. By "innate" we mean those desires that are universal. The desire for food, the desire for companionship, the desire to enjoy beauty are innate desires in this sense. The desires to have a grand house or a PhD are not. The premise cannot be proved but is plausible. We feel hunger; there is such a thing as eating. We feel sexual desire; there is such a thing as sex. It would be unlikely for a race of individuals to exist who reported feeling hungry yet but did not possess food, mouths nor stomachs. For every such innate desire in human experience (save one) we can identify the object.
Minor premise There is a desire for "we know not what" whose object cannot be identified. We are never truly satisfied. For even while we satisfy our hunger, our need for companionship, love, beauty, achievement, etc. The second premise aims to articulate and appeal to the concept of "longing" as expressed by the German term Sehnsucht.
Conclusion If the object of this desire does not exist in this world, it must exist in another.

The argument is not meant to be a proof. The conclusion may not necessarily be the only possibility satisfying the premises. Yet the argument from desire can be persuasive because the premises and conclusion can be not merely understood but "seen" in a much more direct way than similar arguments, such as the Ontological Argument. It is more directly applicable to the human experience.

Criticisms[edit]

The argument from desire has attracted criticisms from both religious and non-religious commentators; whilst using it as evidence for God's existence, Christian philosopher Thomas Aquinas did not consider it a valid argument for the existence of God on its own.[1] In examining the use of the argument from desire in Aquinas's philosophy, historian Robert Pasnau criticises the argument as being "based on strong teleological assumptions few would accept today. It seems clear, contrary to his [Aquinas's] central assumption, that there are things in nature that have no point".

References[edit]

  1. ^ Pasnau, Robert (2002). Thomas Aquinas on Human Nature A Philosophical Study of Summa Theologiae, 1a 75-89. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-00189-2. 

External links[edit]


Original courtesy of Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_desire — Please support Wikipedia.
This page uses Creative Commons Licensed content from Wikipedia. A portion of the proceeds from advertising on Digplanet goes to supporting Wikipedia.
40735 videos foundNext > 

Argument from Desire - Peter Kreeft vs. Richard Norman

Date: July 20, 2013 Location: Unbelievable? Premier Christian Radio Catholic Christian debater: Peter J. Kreeft Atheist debater: Richard Norman For Peter Kre...

argument from desire

This is an argument you don't hear much about. Music is Two Steps From Hell: Legions of Faith What do you think of the music? Would the video be better witho...

The Argument from Desire

More existence of God info can be found at: http://catholicreligionteacher.com/existence-of-god/

Unbelievable Desire (C.S. Lewis and the Argument from Desire)

https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/charisms-visions-tongues-healing/id637027104?at=10lb6F for some experiences from "tasting" the wine (by Dr. Peter Kreeft an...

Is Man More than Matter?: An Argument from the Human Desire for the 5 Transcendentals

In this excerpt of Karlo's presentation on human transcendence, he offers an argument for the immateriality of the human soul from man's desire for the five ...

The Argument for God from Desire Refuted

A simple refutation by analogy of this somewhat unusual argument.

Arguments for God's Existence - Dr Peter Kreeft

1. Argument from Design (0:40) 2. Argument from First Cause (8:04) 3. Argument from Conscience (18:20) 4. Argument from Desire (28:47) 5. Pascal's Wager (34:...

Argument from Disbelief

Theodore Drange proposed a version of the nonbelief argument in 1996. 1) If God exists, God: a) wants all humans to believe God exists before they die; b) ca...

ARGUMENT, Choe Contemporary Dance Company ,Sang-Cheul CHOE

ARGUMENT We are Arguing. Why? The reason is that you are different from me. When we look into the word "arguing", it comes from desire formulated when we can...

Whence a lust for God?

Argument from desire.

40735 videos foundNext > 

We're sorry, but there's no news about "Argument from desire" right now.

Loading

Oops, we seem to be having trouble contacting Twitter

Talk About Argument from desire

You can talk about Argument from desire with people all over the world in our discussions.

Support Wikipedia

A portion of the proceeds from advertising on Digplanet goes to supporting Wikipedia. Please add your support for Wikipedia!